Advanced care planning 2
An advance care plan is a structured and ongoing communication or discussion between a
patient and a professional health caregiver which is meant to communicate the future wishes of
the patient in matters concerning treatment and care options should they not be able to
communicate these wishes at that particular time. (Oliver, 2013, pg 135) The discussion might
also involve a third party such as the patients close family member. Mr. Mario who lives with his
wife, Rosa, is a 46 year old man with stage 4 pancreatic cancer who has just been told by his
oncologist that the chemotherapy treatment he was receiving is no longer effective. Over the past
few days, Mr. Mario has been experiencing symptoms such as nausea. The following is an essay
concerning Mr. Mario’s advance care plan.
Initiating the conversation on advanced care planning
This conversation is meant to discuss with a patient the method and means he would like
to be treated or taken care with once he or she falls seriously ill and he is not able to make such
decisions then. Usually, this conversation is started when it is clear that a patient’s health risk is
very high and so is the case with Mario. The conversation on advanced care planning with Mario
should have been initiated after being told by the oncologist that the chemotherapy was unlikely
to be ineffective and that is the same period when he decided that he would focus on the time he
has with his family. During the initiating of the conversation, it is important to explain to Mr.
Mario what the conversation is all about and the importance. It is after this that he should then be
asked if there is anyone who he thinks should be present during the conversation. This should
then be followed by the deliberate allowing of time so as to provide the patient with an
opportunity to reflect. (Yeung, Escalante & Gagel, 2009, pg.46)
After that, the conversation can then begin and this must be done by using words not too
insensitive to the patient for example, ‘I would like to discuss with you about your wishes of
Advanced care planning 3
future care in case you get very sick which might not happen but just in case it does you will not
be able to express your wishes and at that point it would be very important to know what you
would have wanted’, ‘Have you considered about the place or type of care you would want to
have in case you became too sick to take care of yourself?’ or ‘most people usually think about
what they may want in the future and they usually have their wishes drafted in a document
called Advance Health Directive. Would you like to know more about this Advance Health
Preparing for the conversation
There are some very important issues that should be taken into consideration in
preparation of the advance care planning discussion and this is mostly so as to protect and
maintain the welfare of the patient and this are as follows
Firstly, one should review all medical files notes or files of the patient. This is meant to
ensure that all that all the relevant and critical clinical information concerning the patient are
available. The same can still be achieved through consulting other medical care experts involved
with the patient. (Goldstein & Morrison, 2013, pg 273)
Secondly, the health care professional should also ensure that he or she has a private and
comfortable area to carry out the discussion. This area should be free from interruptions from
anyone. This will help in boosting concentration while collecting all the necessary information.
In addition to finding a private area, one should determine if there is a family member who can
participate in the discussion. This family member should be a very close family member. This
can be determined through scrutinizing the patients’ health and personal documents.
Moreover, it should be made sure that the patient is in a mental capacity to participate in
the discussion. This is so because the patient, if not in the capacity to discuss these matters, can
Advanced care planning 4
easily fall into a depression. If there is a family member participating in the discussion, the same
should also be made sure to avoid any cases of afterwards depression. Chambers, Germain &
Brown, 2010, pg55)
One should ensure that he or she has drafted a structure that will be used during the
advanced care planning process. This can be achieved for example, through having a structure
that contains leading question. The draft structure should be able to contain the following
it should lead one in identifying the goals, advantages and disadvantages
of the methods and interventions that the patient would want sought
it should be able to ensure that the patient knows the level of seriousness
of his stage four pancreatic cancer.
It should be able to lead the patient in knowing that his disease is
It should also be able to identify the patient’s fears or greatest concerns.
It should be able to determine what the patient thinks about the advance
One should have an understanding and be well conversant with all local laws that concern
the drafting and implementation of such critical documentation. One should also ensure
that he or she has adequate knowledge on how to access the necessary documents.
Lastly, arrangements for the appropriate support services should be made prior to the
initiating of the conversation. Among other things, this support service can be helpful in
consoling the patient if he or she gets emotional during the conversation and breaks down.
Who should be involved in the discussion?
Advanced care planning 5
An advanced care planning discussion usually involves a patient and it also advisable
for very close family member to be present although the consent of the patient will have to be
sought first. In the case of Mr. Mario, his close family member is his wife Rosa, so it would
be appropriate to involve his wife in the discussion. Both the participants will be required to
participate in the discussion through sharing their opinions concerning the advance care plan.
Mr. Mario could also choose for his attorney to be present especially if he is interested in
transferring his power of attorney to a different person such as Rosa who would be required
by the power of attorney to make decisions for his husband when the husband is not in a
capacity to do so. Whatever is discussed in the advance care plan is then documented which
will make it easy to use for future references. The wishes are then legalized through filling
out legal forms entailing all your wishes. This can be done with the help of an attorney
although it is not necessary. (Noogle, 2012, pg 57)
Information to be included in the advance care plan
There are issues that should be included in an advance care plan. For an effective
outcome, this should mostly be in the form of questions. The issues to be addressed should be
Firstly, there should be goals, advantages and disadvantages of any interventions that
might be required when taking care of the patient. These goals may include decisions of
emergency treatments to keep the patient alive such cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR)
which is meant to restore the heartbeat if it stops, comfort care which involves relieving pain,
artificial nutrition or artificial hydration which are meant to provide nutrition to the patient
through a tube when the patient is unable eat or drink. This is meant to ensure that Mr. Mario
Advanced care planning 6
fully understands the consequences of any method before preferring for it to be used in the
advance care plan. (Thomas & Lobo, 2011, pg 239)
Secondly, the plan should be able to address the patients preferred place for receiving
future care and this is meant to ensure that the patient is comfortable in receiving this care for
example; this could be asked as ‘where would you prefer to receive future care?’
Although not necessary, the patient should be given the opportunity to decide whether he
would like to donate any organ or tissue in case of death and the question asked could be;
‘incase of death, would you like to donate any of your body organ or tissue? If so where or to
whom would you want the above stated organ or tissue donated?’ (Vadivelu, Kaye & Berger,
2013, pg 100).
The advance care plan should be able to make sure that the patient and his wife are
aware of the extent of seriousness and risk of his pancreatic cancer. This is one of the means
of ensuring that the participants are in the right mental capacity to get involved in the
discussion. For example, this could be asked in the form; ‘are you aware of the extent of risk
of your level four pancreatic cancer? If so what do you think are the risks involved?’
The care plan should be able to inquire from the patient the people he would like to
make decisions for them in case they are unable to make these decisions. The care plan
should still be able to inquire if the patient has shared his wishes with his family or friends.
This could be in the form; ‘Incase your are not able to make any decision, whom would you
like to act in your capacity in making these decisions? Apart from your wife, have you
informed any other family member or friend of your wishes?’
Advanced care planning 7
The plan should be able to diagnose Mr. Mario’s gravest and deepest fears concerning
his pancreatic cancer. The same should also be inquired from his wife, Rosa. For example
this could be asked as ‘what are your deepest fears concerning this disease?’
Lastly, the advance care plan should give Mr. Mario or his wife the opportunity to ask
any question related to Mr. Mario’s health that might have not been addressed in the care
plan. This could be asked as ‘Is there any other issue concerning the disease that you would
want addressed here?’
Reviewing of the advance care plan
This involves the revisiting of the advance care plan discussions and at times the
decisions set out in the advance care plan can be changed. It is usually advisable for the
reviewing to be done regularly due to a number of reasons which can apply in Mr. Mario’s
case. The following are the main reasons for reviewing the plan or circumstances that might
trigger the reviewing process
Firstly, Mr. Mario or his wife could request for the reviewing or change their mind
about a decision that they had made earlier this might for example, be triggered by the
infeasibility of an option that they had recommended maybe due financial constraints or a
number of other issues.
Secondly, there could be a change in circumstances that might require the reviewing
of the plan. For example, change in medical conditions whereby a new disease or condition is
discovered in the patient. The same could also be triggered by change of individual
conditions for example incase Rosa, Mr. Mario’s wife, dies or any other person mentioned in
the advance care plan and whose death affects the plan.
Advanced care planning 8
Thirdly, the reviewing can be done when Mr. Mario returns to the hospital for
example when he is going back for a checkup or when the health care professional visits Mr.
Mario at his home. Usually, the reviewing of the plans is usually set to be done constantly
and in such cases the reviewing is done when the patient visits the hospital or when the
health care professional visits the patient at home. (Hartmann, Loprinzi & Mayo Clinic,
2012, pg 45)
Fourthly, the reviewing can be done if the medical options that are present in the
advanced care plan changes the needs of Mr. Mario in regards to the plan for example in the
discovering of a co morbidity.
Fifthly, Mr. Mario can revoke the advance care plan any time and this will require the
preparation of a new advance care plan. In such a scenario Mr. Mario might view the earlier
on plan as not been appropriate due to a number of reasons and this will require him to
revoke the care plan and request for the drafting of a new one.
Lastly, during the making of the advance care plan, Mr. Mario can state a review
interval of which after the interval time lapses, the making of a new advance care plan will be
required. For example, Mr. Mario could state that he would require reviewing the care plan
after every two months. After the lapse of these two months, Mr. Mario will then be required
to review the care plan.
Activation of the advance care plan
This involves the point and time at which the discussion in the plan will be
implemented. In Mr. Mario’s scenario this will take place under the following circumstances.
Firstly, activation can occur if Mr. Mario enters into a comma for example, after he
collapses at the shopping centre and becomes non responsive and is taken to the hospital. If
Advanced care planning 9
he completely fails to respond, then implementation of the care plan will be deemed
Secondly, the activation can occur in case of Mr. Mario deaths. In this case the
advance care plan will be activated in that, if he had requested in the care plan for his body
tissue or organ to be donated, then his wish will have to be fulfilled. (Barnsteiner, Disch,
Walton & Sigma Theta Tau International, 2014, pg 107)
Thirdly, the activation maybe triggered by the person who has the power of attorney.
This involves transferring your rights to make decisions concerning certain issues to another
person who is required by law to make decisions that will be in your best personal interests if
you are not in a capacity to make these decisions. In this case Mr. Mario could have given
this power to his wife Rosa so if by any chance Rosa feels that Mr. Mario is not in a capacity
to make decisions then she can ask for the implementation of the advance care plan.
Fourthly, the activation of the care plan can be triggered if Mr. Mario experiences
dementia. This is a condition whereby the patient’s mental ability is impaired and cannot
make decisions as a reasonable man. In such a case the patient will not be in the right mental
capacity to make a reasonable decision so this will require the fulfilling of his wishes as he
had earlier on stated in the care plan. (Leah & Susana 2013)
Lastly, the activation can be triggered by a medical condition which will make it
impossible for Mr. Mario to communicate his decisions such as stroke or paralysis. In such a
condition, the patient might be in good mental capacity to make decisions for himself but the
communication of this decision might be difficult hence necessitating the use of his wishes as
stated in the advance care plan
Advanced care planning 10
In conclusion, an advance care plan plays a very crucial role since it betters the
quality of life of the patients, provides medical care which is less aggressive, helps families
prepare for the death of a loved one and also helps in resolving family conflicts. (Thomas &
Lobo, 2011, pg 78)
Advanced care planning 11
Oliver, D. (2013). End of life care in neurological disease. London: Springer
Yeung, S.-C. J., Escalante, C. P., & Gagel, R. F. (2009). Medical care of cancer patients.
Shelton, Conn: People’s Medical Publishing House.
Goldstein, N. E., & Morrison, R.S. (2013). Evidence-based practice of palliative medicine.
Hartmann, L. C., Loprinzi, C. L., & Mayo Clinic. (2012). The Mayo Clinic breast cancer book.
Intercourse, PA: Good Books.
Weis, J,. & Horneber, M. (2014). Cancer related fatigue
Noogle, C. A. (2012). Neuropsychology of cancer and oncology. New York: Springer Pub.
Chambers, E. J., Germain, M., & Brown, E. A. (2010). Supportive care for the renal patient.
Oxford: Oxford University press.
Fischer, S., Gozansky W., Sauaia A., Min S.,Kutner J., Kramer A. (2006). A practical tool to
identify patients who may benefit from a palliative approach: the caring criteria
Shrewsbury, UK: NHS 285
Thomas, K., & Lobo, B. (2011). Advance care planning in end of life care. Oxford: Oxford
In Vadivelu, N., In Kaye, A. D., & In Berger, J. M. (2013). Essentials of palliative care.
Melnyk , B. M., & Fineout-Overhault, E. (2011). Evidence based practice in nursing &
healthcare: A guide to best practice. Philadelphia: Wolters Kluwer/Lippincott Williams
In Christensen, A. J., In Martin, R., & In Smyth, J. M. (2014). Encyclopedia of health
Advanced care planning 12
In LoBiondo-Wood, G., & In Haber, J. (2014). Nursing research: Methods and criticsl appraisal
for evidence-based practice.
Barnsteiner, J. H., Disch, J.M., Walton, M. K., & Sigma Theta Tau International, (2014). Person
and family centered care.
Leah, R., & Susana L. M. (2013). Advance care planning: communicating about matters of life
and death. New York: Springer Pub.